Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Trusted Building Supplies & Hardware Store Since 1933
Since 1933, Goodys Hardware & Paint has served the New Haven community as a trusted, family-owned resource for home improvement and commercial projects. Our fourth-generation team combines deep industry knowledge with personalized service, offering an extensive inventory of hardware, tools, and paint solutions tailored to both residential and business needs. Customers benefit from our 18,000-square-foot East Haven store, where trained professionals provide expert guidance on everything from paint color matching to equipment assembly. We prioritize convenience with same-day delivery for grills and equipment, complimentary propane tank refills, and on-site screen repair services. Our commitment to quality assurance includes certified technicians for propane handling and a satisfaction guarantee on key duplication.With decades of experience in outdoor equipment logistics, we ensure materials reach customers' homes or job sites efficiently. Rapid response times and transparent pricing reflect our dedication to eliminating surprise charges. As a locally rooted business, we maintain strong relationships with manufacturers to carry trusted brands while offering competitive pricing through coupons and online shopping options. Our staff's expertise spans construction, gardening, and seasonal needs, making us a one-stop solution for diverse projects. By combining generational wisdom with modern service standards, we continue delivering reliable, community-focused hardware solutions.
Services
Paint Color Matching
Equipment Assembly
Propane Refills
Key Duplication
Screen Repair
Seasonal Product Supply
Tool Rentals
Hardware Deliveries
Paint Supply Consultation
Outdoor Grill Sales
Details
- Year established: 1933
Highlights and features
- Family-owned since 1933 with generational expertise in hardware and paint
- 18,000-square-foot inventory covering complete home improvement needs
- Certified propane tank technicians with safety inspection services
- Same-day delivery for outdoor equipment and grills
- Complimentary assembly and free old grill removal
What people say
Helpful staff
Comprehensive inventory
Reliable delivery
Generational expertise
Competitive pricing
Services
Paint Color Matching
Our expert Pam matches paint colors to samples, chips, or surfaces using advanced digital technology and traditional techniques. We mix custom orders while you wait, ensuring perfect color consistency for renovation projects. Our quality assurance program verifies paint durability and application standards.
Propane Cylinder Refills
Certified technicians handle propane tank purging and refills with safety inspections included. We maintain strict compliance with industry standards for tank certification and pressure testing while providing efficient service during standard business hours.
Equipment Delivery
We deliver outdoor equipment and bulk materials directly to customer locations with specialized transportation solutions. This includes setup assistance for grills and equipment removal services like free old grill disposal with new purchases.
Key Duplication
On-site key cutting services for residential, automotive, and commercial keys using professional equipment. Our staff creates exact duplicates from existing keys or master templates, maintaining security standards while working quickly.
Screen Repair
Professional screen repair performed onsite with various mesh options including pet-resistant materials. We handle screen door restoration and window screening replacements using durable materials suitable for Connecticut weather conditions.
Questions
What are your store hours?
We operate Monday-Thursday 7am-5:30pm, Friday 7am-5pm, Saturday 7am-4pm, and Sunday 8am-12pm.
Do you offer paint color matching services?
Yes, our paint expert Pam matches colors to samples, chips, or surfaces and mixes custom orders while you wait.
Can you deliver outdoor equipment purchases?
We provide same-day delivery for grills and outdoor equipment, including free removal of old units when purchasing new.
Are propane tank refills available?
Certified technicians refill and inspect propane tanks during standard business hours with safety checks included.
Do you provide screen repair services?
Yes, we repair screens and offer pet-resistant materials for screen doors and window replacements onsite.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept credit cards, cash, and online payments with financing options available for qualified purchases.
Reviews (6)
Tracey Volturno
Jun 17, 2022
Report
Goodys is 110% worth going to. I had to refill my propane for the grill and they gave me heads up that the propane tank that I swapped out, from the gas station on corner of coe and short beach, expired 5 years ago.
Paul Goodman
Mar 14, 2022
Report
Moved away from the area 5 years ago but moving back and Goody's is my favorite good old fashion hardware store. They have everything.
David Asnes
Jan 25, 2022
Report
Excellent Hardware store with everything that you need to complete your project. Very knowledgeable help.
Jonathan Cahoon
Dec 19, 2021
Report
Shop local and understand why. Knowledgeable, helpful. Go to place for home repair needs. Propane fills to screen repair.
Michael Enders
Dec 17, 2021
Report
I am more likely to find what I need, and at a good price st Goody's than at the nearby Home Depot. The staff and management, are helpful, knowledgeable, and friendly.
M. B.
May 02, 2021
Report
Used to be a great store but the management has passed to the next generation and he is NOT nice, not accommodating of repeat customers. so it is often not a pleasant experience. They do have jut about everything, but so do other True Value hardware stores around.
